Web www.GCYArticles.com

GCYArticles.com is an Article Directory featuring thousands of articles written by the Internet's top authors
Search Article Directory:



Or browse through our library of Articles written by the Internet's top authors
What you get at GCYArticles.com

 
Thousands of expertly written Articles
Free Content for your website, ezine, and newsletters
Daily Updates
Receive article updates via RSS Feeds
Real Time and Weekly notifications of New Articles
As an Author

 
Generate massive publicity for your web site
Potential readership of millions for your articles
Increase your traffic and sales
Boost your reputation, credibility, and name recognition
Become known as an Expert in your field

Home | Health & Fitness | Mental Health

Click the XML Icon Above to Receive Mental Health Articles Via RSS!

Print This Article

 Post Comment Add To Favorites Email to Friends Ezine Ready

The Effectiveness Of Psychological Treatments For Treatment Resistant

By: Dr. D.S. Merchant

Depression: A Systematic Review

A systematic review of all studies (controlled and uncontrolled) to evaluate psychological interventions with treatment-resistant depression. One systematic review and two subsequent RCTs including persons 58 years or older with all grades of depressive disorders showed that tricyclic antidepressants, SSRIs, or MAOIs reduced the proportion of persons who did not recover over 28 to 51days compared with placebo.

Background:
About 30% of people with depression do not respond to an antidepressant at the recommended dose and can be described as having treatment-refractory depression.

• Chronicity of Major Depressive Disorder involves many interacting variables
• Resistance to anti-depressant medications

Research issues:
• Definitions used for “treatment resistance”
• Under treatment leading to “pseudo-resistance”
• Inconsistencies in defining “non-response”
• Lack of RCTs / controlled studies
• To examine the effectiveness of psychological treatment interventions for treatment-resistant depression including all controlled and uncontrolled designs

Inclusion Criteria:
• Failure to respond to at least one previous trial of anti-depressant pharmacotherapy
• Participants 18 and above
• ‘Talking treatments’ used as a central component
• Any design and language

Exclusion Criteria:
• Failure to explicitly show non-response to medications in participants prior to study intervention
• Absence of diagnostic criteria fulfillment for depression ( >14 on HRSD or >19 for Beck Depressive Inventory)
• National Health Services (NHS) Centre for Research and Dissemination guidelines for conduct of systematic reviews
• Journals hand-searched (duration mentioned)
• Websites
• Researchers in the field contacted (grey literature)
• Terms ‘depression’ and ‘psychological’,’ depression’ and ‘psychotherapy’, ‘refractory’ and ‘depression’, ‘chronic’ and ‘depression’, ‘resistant’ and ‘depression’
• Language Bias
• Methodological quality was not used for exclusion
• Use of checklist (next slide)
• Publication bias was addressed – using grey literature
• Data extraction was done by one reviewer and checked by second
• Sample size
• Checklist for assessing quality of both randomized and non-randomized health care intervention studies developed by Downs and Black 1998
• Maximum score 32
• Score <12 indicates poor quality
• The checklist is as follows:
• Reporting (10 points)
• External Validity (3 points)
• Internal Validity – Bias (7 points)
• Internal Validity (confounding) – Selection Bias (6 points)
• Power (1 point)

• Are the results clearly displayed?

What are the results?
Method of establishing treatment resistance – few used prospective design
• Heterogeneity with respect to group of medicines received
• Study setting (Inpatient / Outpatient)
• Treatment duration / follow-up variable
• Statistical tests used (only one used ANOVA)
• Only 2 relatively poor RCTs of psychological treatments for treatment-resistant depression are identified
• Methodological issues
• Comparison used Cognitive Therapy

Conclusions:
There is little evidence to guide the management of depression that has not responded to a course of antidepressants. Treatment-refractory depression is an important public health problem and large pragmatic trials are needed to inform clinical practice.

Article Source: http://www.gcyarticles.com

Dr. D.S. Merchant Gold Medalist in (Anatomy & Histology) Resident Medicine Aga Khan University Hospital (AKUH) Karachi. He has written many articles on the topic of Depression, Psychological Treatments and Effectiveness of psychological.

Please Rate this Article

 

Not yet Rated

Additional Articles From - Home | Health & Fitness | Mental Health
Members: Login here

Non-Members: Sign Up for a free account or learn more.
Site Navigation

 
Submit Articles
Top Authors
Most Popular Articles
Submission Guidelines
Ezine Notifications
Article RSS Feeds
 
New Stuff
About Us
Link to Us
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Publisher Guidelines 


© 2006 GCY Article Directory. All Rights Reserved.
Article Directory with Free content for websites and ezines. Authors submit your articles today and gain more exposure.

Powered by Article Dashboard